Overview of "Documentary Evidence" by Charles Hollander

Author and Publication Details

Author: Charles Hollander QC Publication Date: 2023 (Indian Reprint) ISBN: 9789395696364 Format: Hardcover Publisher: Sweet & Maxwell

Key Themes

1. Disclosure Requirements: The book is a comprehensive guide to the disclosure requirements under the law. It provides thorough analysis and practical advice on when and how a practitioner should behave in connection to the disclosure duty.
2. Civil Procedure Rules: It emphasizes the importance of adopting a "cards-on-the-table" approach in exchanging information, not just during litigation but also before it commences. This approach encourages transparency and early identification of relevant documents.
3. Full and Proper Disclosure: The book covers the nature and extent of the disclosure duty, which involves disclosing all documents in possession, custody, or power that are relevant to the topics in question in the case.

Plot Summary

The book is structured chronologically to guide practitioners through the process of disclosure. It begins by explaining the legal obligations surrounding the disclosure of information and progresses to detailed analysis and practical advice on how to handle disclosure duties. The text is logically presented and lucidly written, making it a valuable resource for legal professionals.

Critical Reception

• Comprehensive Guide: The book is widely recognized as a standard work in the field of civil procedure, often cited in court judgments. It is praised for its thorough analysis and practical advice, making it essential for legal practitioners.
• Relevance and Timeliness: The 15th edition, in particular, is noted for its up-to-date coverage of the fast-moving world of civil procedure and the vast amount of caselaw on disclosure and privilege. It is rewritten on a three-year cycle to ensure it remains current.

Editions

• 14th Edition: This edition is specifically mentioned for its thorough guide to disclosure requirements, offering smart and useful suggestions in a clear, logical style.
• 15th Edition: This edition is highlighted for its comprehensive coverage, logical presentation, and detailed analysis. It includes new features and updates on the latest developments in civil procedure and disclosure laws.

In summary, "Documentary Evidence" by Charles Hollander is a seminal work in the field of civil procedure, providing a thorough and practical guide to the disclosure requirements under the law. Its critical reception is positive, with it being frequently cited in court judgments and recognized as a standard work in the field.