Overview of "A Traitor Among the Boys" by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor

Plot Summary: The book "A Traitor Among the Boys" is the fifth installment in Phyllis Reynolds Naylor's series about the Hatford brothers and the Malloy sisters. The Hatford boys have made a New Year's resolution: "the girls can stay . . . but only if they play by our rules." Their mother insists that they treat the girls as if they were their sisters, but the boys' interpretation leans more towards sibling rivalry than brotherly love. Young Peter Hatford is the weak link in this dynamic, as he openly likes the girls and doesn't understand the rivalry. The story follows the humorous pranks and conversations among the children, including an unforgettably embarrassing moment. The narrative also explores the budding affection between Josh and Beth and how all the children come together during a blizzard.

Key Themes:

1. Sibling Rivalry: The book highlights the competitive and often contentious relationship between the Hatford brothers and the Malloy sisters.
2. Friendship and Affection: Despite the rivalry, there are moments of genuine affection and friendship, particularly between Josh and Beth.
3. Humor and Pranks: The story is filled with humorous pranks and conversations that add to its lighthearted and entertaining nature.
4. Community and Unity: The children's actions during a blizzard illustrate their ability to come together and support each other in times of need.

Critical Reception: While specific critical reviews are not provided in the sources, the book is described as a "refreshing series" and "humorous" by Goodreads and Penguin Random House. The Menlo Park Library notes that the book is the fifth humorous installment in the series, indicating a positive reception for the series overall.

Additional Context: The series chronicles the ongoing feud between the Hatford and Malloy families, adding a layer of continuity and character development across the books. Phyllis Reynolds Naylor is known for her engaging and relatable children's literature, making "A Traitor Among the Boys" a delightful read for both children and adults.